Did John Robbins modify Gordon Clark’s writings?

A question not uncommonly asked is whether John Robbins, the first editor of the Trinity Foundation, modified Gordon Clark’s writings in some substantial way when revising and/or reprinting them.

To answer this question I’ve made a quick look over the original published versions of Clark’s books and then compared with them the Trinity Foundation revisions to note modifications made. The results are shown at the bottom of this post. Naturally, I did not compare everything word-for-word, so if you know of other changes please inform me and I will update this post.

My general conclusion from this study (along with the benefit of a number of years of reading Dr. Clark’s books and looking at some of the original manuscripts) is that John Robbins did an honest job with Clark’s writings generally making only minimal edits.

The primary change in the Trinity Foundation revisions of Clark’s books is the addition of forewords, all written by John Robbins except in one case written by Harold Lindsell. These forewords are appropriate considering that Clark wrote to Robbins on 12/5/1984 saying about Trinity Foundation revisions, “So, put in all the Forewords you want.”

Two books—Clark Speaks From the Grave and The Incarnation—have been most frequently under the spotlight.

Though Clark Speaks From the Grave is written in the third person, one should not assume that it is Robbins writing for Clark. In fact, in one of Gordon Clark’s audio lectures he jokes about lectures to be published posthumously. And, settling the issue, it is clear from a letter (GHC to John Robbins, 1/11/1985) in which Clark references having sent the manuscript of Clark Speaks From the Grave to John Robbins, that Clark had finished the volume while yet living and even had known of and approved the title.

Regarding The Incarnation, on 1/13/1985 Clark wrote to John Robbins saying “Another extremely difficult problem is the doctrine of the Incarnation. I have been working on it constantly since moving here, and have some 150 hand written pages.” On 1/25/1985 Clark wrote again to John Robbins saying “My MS on the Incarnation may have 230 handwritten pages. It needs perhaps 25 more as a good conclusion.” Clark would then have had a little more than two months to work on the manuscript before his final illness and death on April 9, 1985. The status of the manuscript as evidenced by these letters correlates well with Robbins’s statement in the preface of the volume that “He [Clark] did not quite finish the book, intending to add a few more paragraphs summarizing his hundred pages of analysis and argumentation, so he asked this writer to complete it for him.” (p. ix)

There is simply no evidence (that I know of) that Robbins modified Clark’s writings in any substantial way.

The only gripe I might have is that Robbins added an editor’s note attempting to correct Clark on one point in the 2nd edition of Predestination. (pp. 85-86) But, even here, this is an editor’s note. It is not a modification of Clark’s writing. The Collected Works editions also contain numerous editor’s notes, but they are clearly labeled as such.

tf 1tf 2tf 3tf 4tf 5

 

Advertisements

About douglasdouma

I am a husband to beautiful wife, an ordained minister in the Reformed Presbyterian Church - Hanover Presbytery, and founder of Sola - Appalachian Christian Retreat (www.discoversola.com). In addition to blogging at this site I am the author of The Presbyterian Philosopher - The Authorized Biography of Gordon H. Clark (Wipf&Stock, 2017) and compiling editor of Clark and His Correspondents: Selected Letters of Gordon H. Clark (Trinity Foundation, 2017). I have a bachelor degree in mechanical engineering (University of Michigan), a master's in business administration (Wake Forest University) and a master of divinity (Sangre de Cristo Seminary). I'm an avid hiker, having completed a northbound thru-hike of the Appalachian trail in 2013 and the first 500 miles of the Pacific Crest Trail in 2016.
This entry was posted in Notes on the thought of Gordon H. Clark. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Did John Robbins modify Gordon Clark’s writings?

  1. Pingback: GHC Review 39: Clark Speaks from the Grave | A Place for Thoughts

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s